Skip to main content
Home

Contracts Entered Into Between Consolidated Constructions Pty Ltd and Main Roads WA and the Public Transport Authority, Inquiry into


Inquiry status:Past
Date commenced:31 Mar 2004
Deadline for submissions:21 Apr 2004
Date Ended:16 Sep 2004
Committee:Public Accounts Committee (2001 - 2005)
House:Legislative Assembly
Important Information:
Terms of Reference:Due to Consolidated Constructions Pty Ltd being placed into administration, the Public Accounts Committee resolved on 31 March 2004 to inquire into the contracts Consolidated Constructions Pty Ltd entered into with Main Roads WA and the Public Transport Authority to complete the seal of the Marble Bar Road and works on the rail track and stations at Armadale and Gosnells.

The Committee will examine the following Terms of Reference and report its findings and recommendations to the Legislative Assembly by 14 September 2004:

1. Whether established tender practices were adopted by Main Roads WA and the Public Transport Authority;

2. How similar tender processes can be improved;

3. Whether the outcome may have been different if improved tender processes had been in place; and

4. Any other related matter that the Committee resolves to consider.

Submission Number Submitting person/organisation
No submissions
Related Documents/Response to Questions on Notice:
Unless a venue is specified, hearings are held at the Legislative Assembly Committee Rooms, Level 1/11 Harvest Tce, West Perth
DateTimeVenueOrganisationWitnessBroadcastTranscript
12 May 200409:30 AMConsolidated Constructions Pty LtdMr John Bell, Mr Michael Badman, Mr Raymond Potter, Mr Steven Yovich, Mr Vincent Yovich
24 May 200410:00 AMState Supply CommissionMr Phil Turner, A/Chief Executive Officer; Mr Bill Hargrave, Acting Director, Strategic Policy and Advice
24 May 200411:15 AMMain Roads WAMr Menno Henneveld, Commisioner of Main Roads WA; Mr Mike Wallwork, Executive Director, Construction and Maintenance Services; Mr Glynn Logue, Manager Contracts; and Mr Bob Hunt, Manager Contract Performance
24 May 200412:15 PMCity of Armadale, City of GosnellsMr Andrew Bruce, City of Armadale; Mr Stuart Jardine, Chief Executive Officer, City of Gosnells
24 May 200401:15 PMPublic Transport AuthorityMr Reece Waldock, Chief Executie Officer; Mr John Leaf, Director of Finance and Contracts
24 May 200402:00 PMSubcontractorsMr Lindsay Berry, LN & CA Berry; Mr Wayne Counsel, Emeco; Mr Peter Cox, Concrete Logistics; Mr Alan Day, AW & C Contractors; Mr A Ducas, Northcoast Holdings; Mr Rod Evans, RNR Contracting; Mr Greg Murphy, Pavement Technology; Ms Fiona Paech, N.W.& F.S.Paech; Mr Dave Shanks, PHS Pty Ltd
25 May 200410:30 AMSeminar Centre, West Pilbara College of TAFE, Millstream Road, KarrathaCarr Civil ContractingMr Mark Blayney, Manager
25 May 200411:30 AMSeminar Centre, West Pilbara College of TAFE, Millstream Road, KarrathaSubcontractorsMr Peter Bywaters, Snowman’s Haulage; Ms Jenny Stewart, KG &JL Stewart
26 May 200409:30 AM East Pilbara Shire Office, Francis Street, Marble BarSubcontractorsMs Ingrid Dick, Marble Bar Caravan Park; Mr David Taylor, DJ & CM Taylor; Mr Ron Gilmore, Sandra Hunt Agencies; Mr Alf Potter, Marble Bar Electrical Service Pty Ltd; Ms Julie Arrowsmith, BM &JH Arrowsmith; Ms Natasha Stubbs, KG Stubbs Earthmoving & Mining
02 Jun 200409:30 AMAdministrator for Carr Civil Contracting Pty LtdMr Nick Persichitti
02 Jun 200410:15 AMConsolidated Constructions Pty Ltd Mr Simon Barnes, Mr Bob Lyons
02 Jun 200411:00 AMAdministrator for Consolidated Constructions Pty LtdMr Gary Anderson
Videos:
Site Visits and Travel Details:25-26 May 2004 - Karratha / Marble Bar
Related Transcripts of Evidence:
Evidence by.. Mr Alfred John Bell (Group Managing Director, Consolidated Constructions Pty Ltd), Mr Michael John Badman (Director, Consolidated Constructions Pty Ltd), Mr Vincent Yovich (Director, Consolidated Constructions Pty Ltd), Mr Steven Yovich (Director, Consolidated Constructions Pty Ltd), Mr Raymond Anthony Potter (Director, Consolidated Constructions Pty Ltd) on 12 May 2004
Evidence by.. Mr Reece Waldock (Acting Chief Executive Officer, Public Transport Authority), Mr John Leaf (Director, Finance and Contracts, Public Transport Authority) on 24 May 2004
Evidence by.. Mr Menno Henneveld (Commissioner of Main Roads, Main Roads Western Australia), Mr Bob Hunt (Manager, Contract Performance, Main Roads Wester Australia), My Glynn Logue (Chartered Professional Engineer, Main Roads Western Australia), Mr Michael Wallwork (Executive Director, Construction and Maintenance Services, Main Roads Western Australia) on 24 May 2004
Evidence by.. Mr William Bruce (Executive Director, Technical Services, City of Armadale), Mr Ray Haeren (Director, Planning and Sustainability, City of Gosnells) on 24 May 2004
Evidence by.. Mr Phillip Turner (Acting Chief Executive Officer, State Supply Commission), Mr William Hargrave (Principal Policy Officer, State Supply Commission), Mr Graham McEachran (Management Consultant, GCM Management Consulting) on 24 May 2004
Evidence by.. Mr Peter Cox (Director, Concrete Logistics), Mr Donald Waugh (Company Director/Accountant, Concrete Logistics), Mr Rodney Evans (General Manager, RNR Contracting Pty Ltd), Mr Lyndon White (Technical Manager, RNR Contracting Pty Ltd), Mr Peter Griffiths (Businessman, Marble Bar Travellers Stop), Mr Donald Harrington (Partner, Marble Bar Travellers Stop), Mrs Fiona Paech (Partner/Subcontractor, N.W. & F.W. Paech), Mr Wayne Paech (Partner/Subcontractor, N.W. & F.W. Paech), Mr Lindsay Berry (Cartage Contractor), Mr Noel Ducas (Director, North Coast Holdings) on 24 May 2004
Evidence by.. Ms Jenny Stewart (Partner, K.G. and J.L. Stewart) on 25 May 2004
Evidence by.. Mr Mark Blayney (Owner-Manager, Carr Civil Contracting Pty Ltd) on 25 May 2004
Evidence by.. Mr Mark Salt (Project/Contract Manager, Main Roads), Mr Arthur Phillips (Manager, Contracts, Main Roads) on 26 May 2004
Evidence by.. Mr David Taylor (Drilling/Blasting Contractor, DJ & CM Taylor), Mr Alfred Potter (Electrical Contractor, Marble Bar Electrical Service), Mr Ronald Gilmour (Manager, Sandra Hunt Agencies), Mr Kevin Stubbs (Director, KG Stubbs Earthmoving and Mining Contractors Pty Ltd), Mrs Natasha Stubbs (Manager, KG Stubbs Earthmoving and Mining Contractors Pty Ltd), Ms Helen Mitchell (Mining Registrar, Department of Industry and Resources), Mrs Julie Arrowsmith (Director, Arrowsmith Transport), Mrs Ingrid Dick (Company Director, Marble Bar Caravan Park), Mr Gerald Dick (Managing Director, Marble Bar Caravan Park) on 26 May 2004
Evidence by.. Mr Nick Persichitti (Accountant, PPB Ashton Read) on 2 Jun 2004
Evidence by.. Mr Gary Anderson (Liquidator, Gary Anderson Chartered Accountant) on 2 Jun 2004
Evidence by.. Mr Robert Lyons (Senior Civil Engineer, Consolidated Constructions Pty Ltd), Mr Simon Barnes (Civil Engineer, Consolidated Constructions Pty Ltd) on 2 Jun 2004