Skip to main content
Toggle Button For website navigation bar
The Legislative Assembly meets today (02:00 PM)
Sitting Today (02:00 PM)
The Legislative Council meets today (02:00 PM)
Sitting Today (02:00 PM)
Public Accounts Committee meet tomorrow (09:15 AM)
Public Accounts Committee
Sitting Today (09:15 AM)
Legislation Committee meet on 30/09/2020 (10:15 AM)
Sitting Today (10:15 AM)
Search this website
Bills (proposed laws)
WA Acts and Regulations (current Laws)
Parliamentary Questions and Answers
Order of Business
Watch and listen
Scrutiny of finances
Find your MP
Members of the Legislative Council (Upper House)
President and Office Holders
Upper House Seating Plan
Members of the Legislative Assembly (Lower House)
Speaker and Office Holders
Lower House Seating Plan
What Members do
Ministers and Shadow Ministers
Find a Former MP
Legislative Council (Upper House)
Legislative Assembly (Lower House)
Find Your MP
Find out what was said in Parliament
Watch and listen
What Parliament does
Make a submission
Contact a member
Vote in an election
Parliamentary Friendship Groups
Former Members Association
Visit and Learn
Plan your visit
Educators and students
Learn how Parliament works
History, house and grounds
Events and exhibitions
Art in Parliament
asked in the
28 November 2017
Hon Robin Scott
28 November 2017
GOLD ROYALTY RATE INCREASE — CONSULTATION
Hon ROBIN SCOTT
to the minister representing the Treasurer:
(1) Is the Treasurer aware that every gold prospector and every director of every goldmining company in Western Australia would welcome and accept an invitation to a consultation with the Treasurer or his representatives?
(2) In respect of the revised gold tax increase announced by the Treasurer on Tuesday, 21 November 2017, will the Treasurer confirm that the government has engaged in consultation with the Chamber of Minerals and Energy of Western Australia?
(3) Will the Treasurer disclose what other entities the government consulted on the same subject; and, if the Treasurer will not so disclose, is it open for honourable members to conclude that there has been no consultation with gold prospectors nor with directors of goldmining companies?
(4) In recalling how his speech to gold industry toilers on 10 October received no applause, not even from his own staff, how does the Treasurer imagine that his new gold tax increase will be accepted by the gold industry and by the huge numbers of companies and individuals supplying the gold industry?
Hon STEPHEN DAWSON
I thank the honourable member for some notice of the question. The following information is provided on behalf of the Treasurer.
(1) The Treasurer and his office consulted the gold companies' representatives. It would be impossible for the Treasurer to consult every stakeholder when government implements its policies. As the member will be aware, industry groups play an important role in that regard. The Minister for Mines and Petroleum consulted a number of specific companies.
(2) The Treasurer and his office consulted the gold sector on the royalty rate change as follows.
On Wednesday, 1 November, the Treasurer phoned the Chamber of Minerals and Energy's chief executive, Reg Howard-Smith, and advised him that the government would be reintroducing the gold royalty rate increase. The Treasurer advised that the government was interested in industry feedback as to how the government might deal with industry concerns in relation to the claimed impacts on marginal mines and small producers, and the claims about the consequential impact on employment.
On Thursday, 2 November, the Treasurer's chief of staff emailed Reg Howard-Smith to seek a meeting with the Treasurer for industry to provide the feedback requested.
On Tuesday, 7 November, the Treasurer and his chief of staff met Mr Howard-Smith and CME deputy chief executive, Nicole Roocke, on the proposed royalty rate increase and had a general discussion about the gold industry's position. Mr Howard-Smith committed to report back the following week.
On Friday, 10 November, the Treasurer's chief of staff phoned the Association of Mining and Exploration Companies' acting CEO, Graham Short, to advise him that the government would be reintroducing the gold royalty rate increase and was interested in industry feedback as to how the government might deal with industry concerns in relation to the claimed impacts on marginal mines and small producers, and the claims about the consequential impact on employment. A meeting was arranged for the following week.
On Tuesday, 14 November, Mr Howard-Smith emailed the Treasurer's chief of staff to say that the industry's response had been delayed until later in the week.
On Tuesday, 14 November, the Treasurer's chief of staff met Mr Short; AMEC CEO, Warren Pearce; and AMEC president, Will Robinson. Mr Robinson advised that AMEC did not support an increase in the gold royalty rate and was not interested in consulting on the issue.
On Thursday, 16 November, Mr Howard-Smith, copying Mr Pearce, emailed the Treasurer's chief of staff to advise that the gold industry's position in relation to the government's proposal to increase the gold royalty rate remained unchanged.
(3) Refer to question (1).
(4) The revised royalty rate change has addressed all of the gold industry's reasonable concerns. The one concern not addressed is the simple fact that the industry does not want to pay a higher royalty rate. It is important that politicians do not outsource their policy positions to industry groups and vested stakeholders, and I expect support for the measure from Western Australia's elected representatives.
Using this website
Acknowledgement of Country
The Parliament of Western Australia is honoured to be situated on the ancestral lands of the Whadjuk Noongar people. The Parliament acknowledges the First Australians as the traditional owners of the lands we represent and pays respects to their Elders both past and present.