Skip to main content
Home
  • The Legislative Assembly meets on 07/05/2024 (01:00 PM)
    Assembly sit 07/05/2024
  • The Legislative Council meets on 07/05/2024 (01:00 PM)
    Council sit 07/05/2024
  • The Public Administration meets on 29/04/2024 (11:00 AM)
    Committee meet 29/04/2024

Parliamentary Questions


Question Without Notice No. 189 asked in the Legislative Assembly on 24 March 2022 by Dr D.J. Honey

Parliament: 41 Session: 1

WESTERN POWER — OUTAGES — PAYMENTS

189. Dr D.J. HONEY to the Minister for Energy:

I refer to the changes to compensation announced yesterday by the McGowan government after the release of the Independent review of Christmas 2021 power outages. Does the minister think this compensation package is sufficient, given that many households lost much more than $120 as a consequence of the blackouts, especially over the Christmas and new year period?

Mr W.J. JOHNSTON replied:

I am very happy to answer the question. I was very interested to participate in the debate on this topic yesterday. I noted a couple of words spoken by the shadow Minister for Energy. One of the sentences he said yesterday was —

I also recall the minister answering a grievance or a question in this chamber �

He claimed that was about the Roleystone outages in 2020. I have been through Hansard. No such grievance or question occurred. I look forward to the member correcting the record and apologising, because there is a word for people who say things they know not to be true; I know it is unparliamentary and I am not going to use it. The member had an opportunity to apologise and correct the record. He also said on the issue of outages —

Going back to May last year, we had the unacceptable situation of 38 Homeswest units � being without power for four days due to a pole collapsing.

He implied that the pole was a Western Power asset and that it was somehow connected to the question of Western Power's reliability. The member knew at the time he said those words that that was a privately owned pole and had nothing to do with Western Power assets. The fact that he came in here and claimed that was an example of Western Power failure shows the sort of person he is.

Dr D.J. Honey: Go and read Hansard.

Mr W.J. JOHNSTON: I am. I look forward to the member standing up and correcting the record, because he is obliged to tell the truth in this chamber and he needs to start doing that. Every time you open your mouth, falsehoods come out. That is the sort of man you are. You are prepared to come into this chamber and say things you know not to be true.

Point of Order

Dr D.J. HONEY: The minister is not answering the question that was asked at all.

The SPEAKER: There is no point of order. I understand the minister has finished his answer in any event. If you would like to ask a supplementary, you can.

Dr D.J. HONEY: He has not finished his answer.

The SPEAKER: You can ask a supplementary if you would like to. I am giving you that invitation.