Skip to main content
Home
  • The Legislative Assembly meets on 07/05/2024 (01:00 PM)
    Assembly sit 07/05/2024
  • The Legislative Council meets on 07/05/2024 (01:00 PM)
    Council sit 07/05/2024
  • The Public Administration meets on 29/04/2024 (11:00 AM)
    Committee meet 29/04/2024

Parliamentary Questions


Question Without Notice No. 630 asked in the Legislative Assembly on 20 October 2021 by Ms M.J. Davies

Parliament: 41 Session: 1

CORONAVIRUS — HEALTH MODELLING

630. Ms M.J. DAVIES to the Premier:

In the absence of a road map for safely reopening our state, will the Premier release the health modelling that has been provided showing the impacts on our hospital system, any legal advice and any other metrics that he is using to make decisions to mandate vaccinations and for future plans to reopen our borders safely?

Mr M. McGOWAN replied:

The advice provided by the Chief Health Officer has already been published, or will be published later on today, so that is a standard occurrence. I remember all of last year Liza Harvey asking me where the advice was and I would show her it was on the website and then she would say, ''Where's the advice?'' It was a common thing. It did not matter how many times I said, ''Here's the advice'' and I gave it to her; she said, ''Where's the advice?'' People will remember that. I do not know why, when I gave her the advice, she did not realise I was giving her the advice. But I gave her the advice all the time and I advised her it was the advice, but she did not seem to understand it was the advice.

First of all, we have tabled that. Secondly, I have advised the member that our expectation is that the border arrangements in relation to New South Wales and Victoria will not come down until next year. I have advised her of that repeatedly. That is the plan. I know some people are saying that we should open for Christmas. I saw the Prime Minister say that a month or so ago. It is an artificial deadline. Christmas is lovely, and I would personally love to go with my family and spend Christmas with my mother and father and my brother and his wife and children in New South Wales. I would love that; that would be great, but I cannot, because if we were to do that, we would run the risk of importing the virus into Western Australia before we get to that extremely high level of vaccination that we want to have. We would then have to put in place public health safety measures, which would cost a lot of people a lot of enjoyment over the Christmas period here in WA and also potentially cost businesses a huge amount of income at their highest earning period in the year.

As I said yesterday, Queensland is different. It relies heavily on the southern states' tourism market, whereas that is not the case here. What would dramatically impact businesses here is if we had importation of the virus prior to Christmas and then had to put in place public health safety measures. Each state is different. That is probably why we are a Federation—each state is different. The longer members go in this political life, the more they realise that states are different. Each state has different nuances and perhaps ours are greater than those of any other state in Australia. Perhaps we are the most different of all the states.

It will be next year. In terms of legal advice, no government has ever tabled the legal advice on these things. Just so the member understands, that is the past practice of all governments. In terms of modelling and those sorts of things, when we are able to provide a further defined date for New South Wales and Victoria, obviously we will provide further advice in relation to that.